An eagle-eyed You fan spotted a massive blunder in one scene from the popular Netflix series — and now it cannot be unseen.
The internet is laughing along with TikTok user @annabellleryan, who pointed out that a profile photo used of Penn Badgley’s creepy protagonist character Joe Goldberg was of a completely different person.
“IM LOSING MY MIND????WHO IS THAT?????? ITS JOEY SILVERBERG,” the user captioned the TikTok video.
The scene being called out is one featuring Joe’s wife Love (played by Victoria Pedretti), who could be seen texting his new boss, librarian Marienne (Tati Gabrielle). But if you zoom into the phone, as the TikTok user did, you’ll realise the profile pic is not of Joe at all.
Other TikTok users were left just as confused by the apparent error, laughing about the photo used.
“That’s Joe Mama,” one user wrote, while another quipped, “That’s Joseph Iceberg.”
Others also referenced Badgley’s character in the teen series, Gossip Girl, where the actor played Dan Humphrey as well as the titular role.
“That’s Dan Humphrey,” one wrote, while another joked, “That’s Gossip Girl.”
But it was one TikTok who said what most were thinking: “How hard would it have been to use a single picture of [Joe] I’m so confused about the laziness lmao.”
You currently holds the number-one spot on Netflix’s Top 10 list. Season 3 premiered on October 15 and sees Joe moving to suburbia with his wife and their newborn son, Henry. As much as Joe tries to change his murderous ways and be a doting dad, things take a dark turn rather quickly.
For a daily dose of 9Honey, subscribe to our newsletter here.